Forums
Fun With Forums
Rules Meeting
|
Capitalization again
Python
|
Fri Jul 13, 2012 1:42 am |
dEUS has always been dEUS and not Deus.
But mr.P found a promo of the "The Jagz Kooner Excursions" using DEUS - capital D.
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1451359
Now, according to the rules, they need to become Deus.
This is a physical promo copy for what initially appears to be a digital-only release. There is no "artwork", as can be seen in the url above. These remixes have also been released on a special edition of Pocket Revolution. The new artwork for this album also clearly states dEUS, and not Deus:
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1122991
Do we really have to apply these rules to a promo release the band had no control over? The public release of these remixes were releases digitally and later physically, clearly labeled "dEUS".
I vote for not taking into account promo releases when applying the capitalization rule.
But mr.P found a promo of the "The Jagz Kooner Excursions" using DEUS - capital D.
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1451359
Now, according to the rules, they need to become Deus.
This is a physical promo copy for what initially appears to be a digital-only release. There is no "artwork", as can be seen in the url above. These remixes have also been released on a special edition of Pocket Revolution. The new artwork for this album also clearly states dEUS, and not Deus:
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1122991
Do we really have to apply these rules to a promo release the band had no control over? The public release of these remixes were releases digitally and later physically, clearly labeled "dEUS".
I vote for not taking into account promo releases when applying the capitalization rule.
| Matt Westwood |
Sun Jul 15, 2012 1:32 am |
This is part of the same issue we had when we discussed multi-artist compilations, again over which artist had limited artistic control over. My view for this matches that: i.e. "what Python said".
Account Login
Statistics
- Bands in tree: 20374
- Albums in tree: 47372
- Artists in tree: 51303
- Previews ♫: 21081
Create Map
Latest Additions
MAPPING THE ROCK 'N ROLL GENOME